Expand Menu
APPETIZERS
Our appetizers are great with lunch, dinner or just a snack.
Mozzarella Sticks
$5.99+
Onion Rings
$2.99+
Mac & Cheese Bites
$5.99+
French Fries
$2.99+
Bread Sticks
$3.99+
Garlic Bread
$2.99+
Sampler Platter
(2) Chicken fingers, (2) Mozzarella sticks, (4) Poppers, (2) Pizza Logs, & (1) order of onion rings.
$13.99
Cheese Fries
$4.99
Hot Poppers
$4.99+
Fried Dough
$3.99
Pizza Logs
$5.99+
Sweet Potato Fries
$3.99
Tator Tots
$3.99
Funnel Cake Fries
$2.99+
SALADS
We use the finest ingredients in every salad including cold, fresh, crisp lettuce, red ripe tomatoes, and croutons.
Chef Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, black olives, and cheddar.
$3.99+
Antipasto Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, mozzarella, black olives and green olives.
$4.99+
Grilled Chicken Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, chicken, mozzarella.
$4.99+
Chicken Finger Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, chicken, mozzarella, and cheddar.
$4.99+
Tuna Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, tuna, and mozzarella.
$4.99+
Taco Salad
$4.99+
Julienne Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, turkey, ham, mozzarella, and cheddar.
$4.99+
COMBO SPECIAL
Coupons cannot be used with specials.
Mini Sub Special
Add fries & 20 oz. soda for only $1.99 with the purchase of any mini sub!
$6.98+
Chicken Finger Special
3 Fingers & Fries with Blue Cheese, Celery & Carrot Sticks & 20 oz. Soda.
$8.99+
Small Pizza for Two Special
Small Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 10 Wings or 5 Fingers.
$16.99+
Two Large Pizza Special
2 Large Pizzas Cheese + 1 Item
$24.99+
Family Value Special
Large Cheese + 1 Item Pizza and 20 Wings
$27.99+
Large Pizza & 30 Wings Special
With Cheese + 1 item
$34.99+
Sheet Pizza & 30 Wings Special
with Cheese + 1 Item
$42.99+
1 Sheet Pizza & 50 Wings Special
With Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 50 regular wings or 25 fingers.
$53.99+
2 Large Special & 50 Wing Special
With Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 50 regular wings or 25 fingers.
$53.99+
SPECIALTY PIZZAS
White Pizza
Brushed with house oil, covered with fresh tomatoes, onions, blended cheeses, and sprinkled with seasonings
$14.99+
Veggie Pizza
Broccoli, mushrooms, onions, choice of peppers, choice of olives, sprinkled with Romano cheese.
$14.99+
Taco Pizza
Choice of taco, steak or chicken, topped with fresh lettuce, black olives, tomato and blended cheeses.
$14.99+
Garlic Bread Pizza
Topped with cheese, garlic bits and seasoning.
$10.99+
Chicken Finger Pizza
Your choice of Hot/Med/Mild or BBQ sauces, covered with mozzarella cheese and chopped chicken fingers. Served with bleu cheese on the side.
$14.99+
Steak Pizza
Brushed with house oil, blended cheeses, choice of peppers, onions and chopped steak.
$14.99+
In The Grass Pizza
Choice of chicken or steak, brushed with house oil, mixed with fresh garlic, spinach, covered with blended cheeses.
$14.99+
Grilled Chicken and Broccoli Pizza
Brushed with house oil, with chicken, broccoli, choice of peppers, covered with blended Cheeses.
$15.99+
Carnivore Pizza
A mix of steak, sausage & chicken with sauteed onions, peppers, covered with blended cheeses & sprinkled with seasonings.
$15.99+
Rodeo Pizza
A BBQ red sauce with ground beef, covered with blended cheeses, topped with onion rings, lettuce & tomato.
$14.99+
Stinger Pizza
A generous portion of steak & chicken finger covered in mozzarella cheese with a layer of lettuce & tomato.
$15.99+
Hawaiian Pizza
A classic ham & pineapple pizza.
$14.99+
Pulled Pork Pizza
Homemade pulled pork smothered in BBQ sauce with option to add onions & choice of peppers, covered with mozzarella cheese.
$14.99+
Stuffed Banana Pizza
Red sauce base pizza covered with homemade stuffed banana peppers & garlic.
$15.99+
SUBS & WRAPS
Our subs features toasted Costanzo’s rolls, fresh lettuce, tomatoes, cheese & your choice of mayo or seasoned oil. Onions only on request. Wraps available in flour tortillas.
Ham
Cold
$4.99+
Turkey
Cold
$4.99+
Ham & Turkey
Cold
$4.99+
Salami
Cold
$4.99+
Cheese Sub
Cold
$4.99+
Tuna
Cold
$4.99+
Capicola
Cold
$5.99+
Assorted
Cold
$5.99+
Turkey Club
Cold
$6.99+
Pizza
Hot
$4.99+
White Pizza
Hot
$5.99+
Sausage
Hot
$5.99+
Steak
Hot
$5.99+
Chicken Fingers
Hot
$6.99+
Chicken Fingers Pizza Sub
Hot
$6.99+
Grilled Chicken
Hot
$7.49+
BLT
Hot
$6.99+
Royal
Hot
$6.99+
Cheeseburger
Hot
$6.99+
Bacon Cheeseburger
Hot
$7.49+
Stinger
Hot
$7.49+
Fish
Hot
$9.99+
In The Grass
$6.99+
Parmesan
$5.99+
Hoagie
$6.99+
The Pizza Heist
The Pizza Heist is the restaurant to get a meal for a steal in Lancaster, NY. Since 2012, we’ve been creating gourmet pizzas you won’t find just anywhere—try our Rodeo Pizza, topped with onion rings! No matter what day or time you’re craving our pizza, chances are we’re open. For lunch or dinner, we have meals your whole family can enjoy. Call ahead or walk in; we offer takeout and delivery. In addition to pizzas, we have a tasty selection of subs, tacos, salads, wraps, dinner plates, and appetizers. Our cooks work with fresh ingredients to deliver high quality food and impeccable service daily. If you’re looking for delicious pizza to enjoy as a hot meal at home or at an upcoming event, stop in The Pizza Heist—we’ll take care of you! Place an order online today for carryout or delivery! We are located just west of Como Lake County Park!99%
of 646 customers recommendedHours of Business
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday and Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM