0 items in Cart
The Pizza Heist Logo
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Specials
  • Hours/Directions
  • Contact Us
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Specials
  • Hours/Directions
  • Contact Us
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

The Pizza Heist Online Ordering Menu

231 Aurora St.
Lancaster, NY 14086
(716) 681-1111
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
98% of 1,723 customers recommended
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability

MONDAY SPECIAL

Large Cheese + 1 Item Pizza  
$11.95+

TUESDAY SPECIAL

3 Beef & Cheese Tacos 
3 tacos for the price of 2!
$11.98+
3 Chicken Finger Tacos 
3 tacos for the price of 2!
$13.98+
3 Veggie Tacos 
3 tacos for the price of 2!
$9.98+
3 Steak Tacos 
3 tacos for the price of 2!
$13.98+

WEDNESDAY SPECIAL

Buy 1 Whole 12" Sub - Receive $1 off 
$8.99+

FRIDAY SPECIAL

Buy any *LARGE* pizza combo and receive a FREE 2 liter pop.
Large Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 20 Wings, Free 2 Liter Pop 
$36.99+
Large Pizza & 30 Wings Special with 2-Liter Pop 
With Cheese + 1 item.
$47.99+
Large Pizza & 30 Boneless Wings Special with 2-Liter Pop 
With Cheese + 1 item.
$35.99+

APPETIZERS

Our appetizers are great with lunch, dinner or just a snack.
Mozzarella Sticks 
$5.99+
Onion Rings 
$2.99+
Mac & Cheese Bites 
$5.99+
French Fries 
$2.99+
Bread Sticks 
$3.99+
Garlic Bread  
$2.99+
Sampler Platter  
(2) Chicken fingers, (2) Mozzarella sticks, (4) Poppers, (2) Pizza Logs, & (1) order of onion rings.
$13.99
Hot Poppers 
$5.99+
Fried Dough 
$3.99
Pizza Logs 
$5.99+
Tator Tots 
$4.99
Funnel Cake Fries 
$2.99+
Apple Pie Logs 
$5.99

SALADS

We use the finest ingredients in every salad including cold, fresh, crisp lettuce, and red ripe tomatoes.
Chef Salad 
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, black olives, and cheddar.
$5.99+
Antipasto Salad 
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, mozzarella, black olives and green olives.
$6.99+
Grilled Chicken Salad 
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, chicken, mozzarella.
$6.99+
Chicken Finger Salad 
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, chicken, mozzarella, and cheddar.
$6.99+
Tuna Salad  
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, tuna, and mozzarella.
$6.99+
Taco Salad  
$6.99+
Julienne Salad 
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, turkey, ham, mozzarella, and cheddar.
$6.99+

TACOS

Served on a soft tortilla shell with shredded lettuce, tomato & cheese. Hot/Medium/Mild
Beef & Cheese 
$5.99+
Chicken Finger 
$6.99+
Veggie 
$4.99+
Steak 
$6.99+

PIZZA & WING SPECIALS

Coupons cannot be used with specials.
Mini Sub Special  
Add fries & 20 oz. soda for only $2.99 with the purchase of any mini sub!
$8.23+
Chicken Finger Special  
3 Fingers & Fries with Blue Cheese, Celery & Carrot Sticks & 20 oz. Soda.
$10.99+
Small Pizza for Two Special 10 Boneless Wings 
Small Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 10 Boneless Wings
$14.99+
Small Pizza for Two Special 10 Regular Wings 
Small Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 10 Wings.
$19.99+
Small Pizza for Two Special 5 Chicken Fingers  
Small Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 5 Chicken Fingers
$19.99+
Two Large Pizza Special  
2 Large Pizzas Cheese + 1 Item
$24.99+
Large Pizza and Chicken Wings 
Large pizza and 20 wings
$36.99+
Large Pizza and Boneless Wings 
Large pizza and 20 boneless wings.
$25.99+
Large Pizza and Chicken Fingers 
Large pizza & 10 chicken fingers
$38.99+
Large Pizza & 30 Wings Special 
Large pizza and 30 wings
$47.99+
Large Pizza & 30 Boneless Wings Special 
Large pizza and 30 boneless wings
$34.99+
Sheet Pizza & 30 Wings Special  
with Cheese + 1 Item
$55.99+
Sheet Pizza & 30 Boneless Wings 
with Cheese + 1 Item
$43.99+
1 Sheet Pizza & 50 Wings Special  
With Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 50 regular wings.
$72.99+
1 Sheet Pizza & 50 Boneless Wings Special  
With Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 50 boneless wings.
$56.99+
1 Sheet Pizza & 25 Chicken Fingers 
With Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 25 chicken fingers.
$78.99+
2 Large Special & 50 Wings 
With Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 50 regular wings.
$72.99+
2 Large Special & 50 Boneless Wings 
With Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 50 boneless wings.
$56.99+
2 Large Special & 25 Chicken Fingers 
With Cheese + 1 Item Pizza & 25 chicken fingers.
$78.99+

PIZZA

Your choice of a regular or thin crust.
Build Your Own Pizza 
$8.99+

SPECIALTY PIZZAS

White Pizza  
Brushed with house oil, covered with fresh tomatoes, onions, blended cheeses, and sprinkled with seasonings
$15.99+
Veggie Pizza 
Mushrooms, onions, choice of peppers, choice of olives, and cheese.
$15.99+
Taco Pizza 
Choice of taco, steak or chicken, topped with fresh lettuce, black olives, and tomato.
$15.99+
Garlic Bread Pizza  
Topped with cheese, garlic bits and seasoning.
$11.99+
Chicken Finger Pizza 
Your choice of Hot/Med/Mild or BBQ sauces, covered with mozzarella cheese and chopped chicken fingers. Served with bleu cheese on the side.
$15.99+
Steak Pizza 
Brushed with oil, mozzarella cheese, choice of peppers, onions, and chopped steak.
$15.99+

CHICKEN FINGERS

Served with fries, bleu cheese, and celery. Covered with your choice of sauce.
5 Pieces 
$14.99+
10 Pieces 
$26.99+
15 Pieces 
$36.99+
25 Pieces 
$55.99+

CHICKEN WINGS

Every order served with bleu cheese, celery, and carrots. Served with your choice of sauce.
10 Piece 
$13.99+
20 Piece 
$26.99+
30 Piece 
$38.99+
50 Piece 
$59.99+

BONELESS WINGS

Every order served with bleu cheese, celery, and carrots. Served with your choice of sauce.
10 Piece 
$9.99+
20 Piece 
$17.99+
30 Piece 
$25.99+
50 Piece 
$38.99+

SUBS & WRAPS

Our subs features toasted Costanzo’s rolls, fresh lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and your choice of mayo, oil, or onions. Wraps available in flour tortillas.
Ham 
Cold
$7.99+
Turkey 
Cold
$7.99+
Ham & Turkey 
Cold
$7.99+
Salami  
Cold
$7.99+
Cheese Sub 
Cold
$7.99+
Tuna 
Cold
$7.99+
Capicola  
Cold
$8.99+
Assorted  
Cold
$8.99+
Turkey Club 
Cold
$9.99+
Pizza  
Hot
$7.99+
Sausage  
Hot
$8.99+
Steak 
Hot
$8.99+
Chicken Fingers 
Hot
$9.99+
Chicken Fingers Pizza Sub 
Hot
$9.99+
Grilled Chicken 
Hot
$9.99+
BLT 
Hot
$9.99+
Royal 
Hot
$9.99+
Cheeseburger 
Hot
$9.99+
Bacon Cheeseburger 
Hot
$12.99+
Stinger 
Hot
$13.99+
Parmesan 
$0.00+
Hoagie 
$9.99+

DRINKS

Bottled Drink (20 Oz.) 
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Cherry Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Dr. Pepper, Mountain Dew, Ginger Ale, Root Beer, Water, Red Gatorade , Purple Gatorade, Yellow Gatorade, Peach Tea, Lemon Tea, Diet Green Tea, or Diet Dr. Pepper.
$1.99
2 Liter Soda 
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Cherry Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Dr. Pepper, Mountain Dew, or Ginger Ale.
$2.99
Your cart is empty.
Accepts Google Pay
Accepts Venmo


  • Visit our Facebook Visit our Yelp Visit our Twitter Visit our Instagram
Powered by Menufy © 2023
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.